By Andrew T. Austin. Adapted from my video published on 8 April 2021.
“What does the stalker want?” often means “What can I do to make this end?” It is an understandable question from somebody facing persistent unwanted attention. It can also lead to a misleading assumption: that there must be one need which, once satisfied, will bring the behaviour to a close.
In this video I examine that assumption, the attraction of clever responses, and the difference between reducing engagement and expecting an instant solution. The discussion also considers how public reactions can extend the audience and provide material for further manipulation.
The appeal of the clever reply
When people hear about stalking, many immediately suggest the thing they believe will stop it. Deliver a threat. Use a particular sentence. Make a public post. Arrange for somebody authoritative to speak to the person.
I encountered these suggestions during my own experience, particularly among people interested in therapy, coaching and personal development. Their confidence often depended on an imagined conversation in which the right words would produce the right insight.
The difficulty is that the recipient may not be participating in the conversation imagined by the adviser. A statement meant to end contact can be experienced as renewed contact. A hostile response can still demonstrate that persistence has produced attention.
What a delayed response can communicate
The recording refers to an example associated with Gavin de Becker’s The Gift of Fear. If repeated unwanted calls and emails are eventually followed by a reply, the person making contact may learn that persistence is rewarded. The intended message might be “stop”; the behavioural result is that a response finally occurred.
The numbers in the example illustrate repetition rather than provide a formula. The point is that the meaning intended by the sender is not the only effect of sending a message.
This does not mean that a victim who has replied is responsible for subsequent harassment. People respond under pressure, fear, exhaustion or practical necessity. It means that future communication deserves careful consideration within a safety plan, rather than being improvised around the hope that one final explanation will settle everything.
A promised bargain may not be an endpoint
“Do this and I will leave you alone” presents the unwanted contact as a problem the target can solve by complying. But a demand can also function as a way to retain access and direct another person’s behaviour.
The test is not how confidently an endpoint is promised. It is the wider pattern. Have boundaries been respected? Have previous agreements held? Do new conditions appear whenever the old ones are addressed?
In the recording I argue that ongoing involvement may be the thing being maintained. That is why satisfying a stated demand does not necessarily settle the relationship. Where practical obligations exist, a professional or formal channel may be needed to handle those matters without reopening unlimited personal engagement.
The imagined relationship
I use the idea of an internal “avatar” to describe a relationship taking place largely within the pursuer’s own account of the target. They may have a fixed story about who the other person is, what the relationship means, and how that person ought to respond.
The real person does not behave in accordance with that story. Instead of revising it, the pursuer may pressure, accuse or harass the target in an attempt to make reality fit the expectation.
This is a way of describing a possible interpersonal pattern, not a diagnosis or an explanation of every stalking case. Its usefulness lies in showing why clearer explanations may fail. The target is trying to communicate their actual position while the other person continues to insist on a different role for them.
Grievance can reverse the roles
The recording also explores the possibility that the pursuer regards themselves as wronged. From that position, the target’s withdrawal is interpreted as an injustice and attempts to seek protection become further evidence of mistreatment.
This creates a circular account: the target is said to deserve punishment, and resistance to the punishment is treated as proof that it was deserved. The target cannot solve the circle simply by explaining that they disagree.
An apparently affectionate fixation can contain the same contradiction. Admiration does not guarantee respect for the other person’s wishes. When affection becomes entitlement, a refusal may be interpreted as betrayal. The relevant issue is how the person behaves in response to another person’s autonomy, not the positive language used to describe the attachment.
No contact has limits
I strongly advocate avoiding engagement in the video, but also explicitly say that ignoring the person may not make them go away. Those two statements are central to understanding the advice. Reducing interaction aims to avoid extending the relationship; it does not offer a guarantee that the conduct will end.
Individual circumstances matter. Shared children, employment, legal duties or other unavoidable connections can make absolute no contact impractical. Decisions about blocking, preserving incoming messages and necessary communication should be made with appropriate support.
Specialist advice can help establish a safe boundary and an appropriate channel for anything that must be addressed. Continued harassment despite that boundary is not evidence that the victim has failed to find the right technique. Responsibility remains with the person pursuing the unwanted conduct.
Indirect posts can still be a response
It is possible to stop direct messages while continuing the exchange through public posts. A vague update about an unnamed person, a statement of outrage, or a warning addressed to “whoever is doing this” may be recognisable to the person involved.
Other readers can then become an audience. They ask questions, speculate, share material or offer interventions. A situation that the target wants to end gains more participants and more visible activity.
The concern is not that distress is inappropriate. Fear and anger make sense under pressure. The question is where those feelings can be expressed without supplying more public material or attracting unwanted involvement. A confidential conversation with a trusted supporter has a different function from a post addressed to an indefinite audience.
Public words can be detached from their context
A person responding in anger may assume that everybody will understand the provocation. Later, a screenshot or quotation may circulate without the preceding months of conduct. The reply then becomes the apparent event, while the history that gave rise to it is less visible.
The video uses threats and publication of personal details as examples of responses that can create additional problems. They can increase conflict and complicate the factual account that another person is trying to understand.
The recording’s demand to be a “perfect victim” describes the pressure of that scrutiny, but should not be treated as a legal test. A person does not lose the right to support because they have been angry, distressed or inconsistent. The practical purpose of restraint is to avoid adding risk and confusion, not to make the victim earn sympathy.
Protection is a process rather than a phrase
The desire for a decisive intervention is understandable. A police warning, a court order or a change in circumstances can feel like the moment after which everything ought to be different. The recording cautions against assuming that the other person’s fixation necessarily disappears at that point.
That is a reason for continued planning and appropriate professional involvement, not for giving up on legal protection. No-contact boundaries, evidence, specialist support and legal measures serve different functions and may need to work together.
The question can therefore become more practical: what reduces access, what information needs preserving, who needs to know, and what should happen if the person makes contact again? Those questions direct attention towards actions and responsibilities that can be discussed with qualified support, rather than an imagined sentence that will finally change the pursuer’s mind.
Related short excerpts
These short clips revisit individual points from the full discussion.
- Stalking: the problem with ‘magic words’
- Stalking and the imagined relationship
- Stalking: public posts and courtroom perceptions
- Stalking: no contact and public responses
- What does a stalker want?
- Stalking: a short excerpt on no contact
Read the stalking series
- Stalking and the Problem of Other People
- Stalking, Social Networks and Smear Campaigns
- Stalking, Manipulation and the Two Kinds of Lie
- When Stalking Begins: Before the Target Recognises It
See also On Stalking and Being Stalked and the General Writings hub.
Support and source material
Watch the original video. For support with your own circumstances, contact the National Stalking Helpline.
Legal context: CPS guidance on stalking or harassment in England and Wales.
This is an edited account of the video, with historical observations distinguished from present-day guidance. Individual safety and legal decisions require advice appropriate to the circumstances.