By Andrew T. Austin. Adapted from my video published on 5 November 2020.
“If you do this, I will leave you alone.” It sounds like an offer of an endpoint. For somebody exhausted by unwanted contact, that can be a powerful temptation. In the third video in my stalking series, I examine why such promises may function as a means of keeping the interaction alive.
The recording also distinguishes two forms of deception: an account built around true details but given a false meaning, and an accusation that is entirely fabricated. Both can pull the target into a public exchange that supplies further attention and material.
Recognising a pattern beyond your own situation
The video begins with an observation about accounts shared on a stalking support forum. The circumstances differed, but certain questions and behaviours appeared repeatedly. How long will this continue? What does the person want? What can I do to make it stop?
Recognising similarities can reduce the feeling that every aspect of the situation must be explained by something uniquely wrong with you. It can also help name a pattern that otherwise feels bewildering.
Shared experiences still have limits. An online account cannot establish the risk in another person’s case, and advice from a discussion forum cannot replace an individual assessment. The value I describe is recognition and perspective, rather than treating strangers’ experiences as a universal instruction manual.
The demand may be a means of maintaining contact
The phrase “stalkers stalk because they like stalking” is the central provocation of the video. I use it to challenge the assumption that the behaviour must be directed towards a reasonable final settlement. In some patterns, the ongoing pursuit itself provides attention, a sense of involvement or opportunities for control.
This is an interpretation of the behaviour discussed in the recording, not a claim that every person who stalks has an identical motivation. The practical distinction is between a genuinely limited request and a request that continually changes whenever the target attempts to satisfy it.
If one explanation is followed by another question, one concession by another condition, or one payment by another demand, the promised endpoint keeps moving. The target can become occupied with solving a problem that the other person has an interest in keeping open.
Promises and threats can work together
A promise to stop may be paired with a threat to do something worse. The recording gives examples such as threatening to contact an employer, approach colleagues or publish private material. Both sides of the offer place pressure on the target: comply to obtain relief, or refuse and be blamed for the next escalation.
That framing attempts to transfer responsibility. The person making the threat remains responsible for their conduct. Being offered a condition does not turn harassment into a legitimate bargain.
Nor can the target safely assume that meeting the demand will prevent the threatened behaviour. Where threats are involved, preserve what has been received and obtain specialist advice. The decision about communication needs to account for the particular risk, rather than rely on the threat-maker’s assurance.
A business dispute and the use of formal boundaries
I describe a separate experience in a business context where the demands became increasingly elaborate. I believed that directly satisfying an early demand would create a further connection and lead to more demands. I preferred the prospect of a formal process in which other professionals would be involved and the issues could be defined.
That was my assessment of a particular situation. It is not advice to ignore debts, legal correspondence, court papers or contractual obligations. A genuine obligation and inappropriate behaviour can coexist. A lawyer can help separate what must be addressed from what is an attempt to prolong personal contact.
The useful principle is containment: where a practical dispute exists, a clear process and an appropriate representative can limit improvisation. The target does not have to personally negotiate every new version of an accusation or demand.
The first kind of lie: true details with a false frame
A truth-based distortion preserves enough recognisable detail to appear credible. A meeting happened, a message was sent, or certain words were spoken. The alteration may lie in the motive attributed to the speaker, the omission of surrounding context, or a small change that transforms the meaning.
This makes the lie difficult to confront. Saying that none of it happened would be inaccurate, yet accepting the factual fragments can be made to look like acceptance of the entire allegation. The target may feel compelled to reconstruct a lengthy history to explain a relatively short claim.
In the video I describe this as a drop of poison in an otherwise recognisable account. The audience sees familiar facts and may not notice that the interpretation linking them together has been supplied by the person making the accusation.
An organised record helps separate the event from the meaning later attached to it. The original exchange may show what preceded the quoted sentence, what was actually requested or who said the words. That material is generally more useful in a responsible evidential process than in an escalating public argument.
The second kind of lie: an entirely invented accusation
The other form is the grandiose lie, an accusation with no factual basis. Its apparent strength can come from an audience’s reluctance to believe that somebody would invent something so substantial.
A complete denial may then be received with suspicion. Observers assume there must be some truth somewhere, and interpret the target’s certainty as evasiveness. This is the reasoning behind “there is no smoke without fire”: the accusation is treated as evidence merely because it has been made.
The video describes how this can create a no-win public exchange. A short denial seems inadequate; a detailed answer gives the allegation more space; visible anger becomes another object of discussion.
My warning against denying such claims concerns that informal cycle. It should not be interpreted as a requirement to leave formal allegations unanswered. Accurate responses to police, courts, regulators or employers may be essential and should be prepared with appropriate advice.
An explanation can travel back to its subject
The audience is not always separate from the person making the allegations. Someone who appears sympathetic may also be a friend, colleague or intermediary of that person. What is said privately can therefore become part of the next public account.
This is why the identity and role of a listener matter. Familiarity on social media does not establish confidentiality. Nor does saying “I am only trying to help” explain what the person intends to do with the information.
The target can set a simple boundary around this: support is welcome, but passing messages, investigating the other person or conducting negotiations is not an invitation that has automatically been given. A supporter’s respect for that boundary is more useful than enthusiasm for the story.
Duration, uncertainty and continuing support
People naturally want to know when the situation will end. In the recording I explain that my own experience lasted just over two years and ended after the person involved died before trial. That personal history cannot establish how another case will develop.
The video also raises the possibility of unwanted contact continuing through third parties or after a legal intervention. A change in circumstances does not automatically answer every question about future contact. Equally, persistence is not proof that nothing can help.
The workable task is to review the pattern, preserve the evidence and keep support appropriate to the current circumstances. A promised ending, a new accusation or a period of silence can all feel decisive in the moment. Each needs to be understood within the wider history rather than treated as a reason to abandon the boundaries and support already established.
Related short excerpts
These short clips revisit individual points from the full discussion.
- Stalking: when your words are used against you
- Stalking: when contact continues from prison
- Stalking: threats and manipulation
- Stalking: partial truths and grandiose lies
- Stalking: promises to leave you alone
Read the stalking series
- Stalking and the Problem of Other People
- Stalking, Social Networks and Smear Campaigns
- When Stalking Begins: Before the Target Recognises It
- What Does a Stalker Want? Responses, Boundaries and Their Limits
See also On Stalking and Being Stalked and the General Writings hub.
Support and source material
Watch the original video. For support with your own circumstances, contact the National Stalking Helpline.
This is an edited account of the video, with historical observations distinguished from present-day guidance. Individual safety and legal decisions require advice appropriate to the circumstances.