By Andrew T. Austin. Adapted from my video published on 20 August 2020.
The difficulty of stalking can extend far beyond the person making unwanted contact. Friends, colleagues and acquaintances may already know that person, like them, work with them or accept their account of events. When the target finally speaks about what is happening, the surrounding group may have heard a different story for months.
In the second video in this series, I explore that social problem. The central issue is how the history of a relationship, and the way that history has been presented to others, can make stalking look like a mutual disagreement.
Recognition is not necessarily the beginning
We often date the start of stalking from the moment we recognise it. That is understandable: something becomes clearly wrong, a boundary is breached, or unwanted contact continues after the relationship changes. Yet the point of recognition may be later than the beginning of the intrusive interest.
In some situations, the person has already spent considerable time within the target’s social or professional world. They may have become friends with the target’s friends, attended shared events or developed business relationships with mutual acquaintances.
This does not mean that every earlier interaction was deliberately planned or that ordinary friendship is evidence of stalking. The useful question is whether later conduct reveals a pattern that was difficult to see at the time. New information can change how an earlier sequence is understood.
The social network gives a story credibility
A person who is well integrated into a group does not appear to observers as an obvious outsider. Other people have their own friendly experiences of them. Those experiences can make it difficult to accept that the same person behaves very differently towards a particular target.
Their presence in the group can also provide access to information. A casual conversation may disclose travel plans, a work event or an update on someone’s private life. A mutual friend may pass a message without recognising that they are helping to maintain unwanted contact.
The resulting problem is relational as well as practical. The target may feel that withdrawing from the person means withdrawing from an entire community. At the same time, asking everybody to choose sides can turn the situation into a public dispute, creating further opportunities for intervention and gossip.
Small suggestions can prepare a larger story
A smear campaign does not always begin with a dramatic accusation. It can develop through minor suggestions, ambiguous remarks and repeated expressions of concern that portray the target as difficult, unstable or untrustworthy. Each comment may appear too slight to challenge.
In the video I describe this as putting small drops of poison into the well. The influence lies in accumulation. By the time a more explicit accusation appears, the audience may feel that it fits something they already knew, even though that supposed knowledge came from the same source.
The target’s eventual distress can then be interpreted through the prepared story. An attempt to explain the problem becomes evidence of being troublesome. Anger becomes evidence of aggression. The frame has been established before the person has an opportunity to describe their experience.
Reversing who said what
I give an example from a business context in which somebody contacted people about negative remarks that had been made, but attributed those remarks to me. The words and the subject matter were familiar; the claimed speaker was different.
This created a difficult position. A simple denial could be heard as an ordinary argument about who said what. A detailed explanation would require discussing the same people again and could itself be repeated out of context.
The broader mechanism is a reversal of responsibility. Conduct associated with the person creating the problem is attributed to the target. In stalking situations, this can include presenting the target as the pursuer or claiming that the target is responsible for the conflict. The existence of competing accusations does not, by itself, establish that responsibility is equal.
Why bystanders look for a mutual dispute
People often try to make a situation intelligible by fitting it into a familiar story. Two people once knew each other, something went wrong, and now both are upset. From that viewpoint, compromise or a conversation seems like the obvious answer.
The difficulty is that this account can overlook persistence, unwanted contact and the refusal to accept a boundary. It places the burden on both parties to repair a relationship when one party may be trying to end participation in it.
Past intimacy or friendship does not supply permanent permission for access. A history of arguments also does not establish that repeated unwanted pursuit is a reasonable response. The relevant behaviour needs to be examined in context, rather than explained away through assumptions about what the target must have done.
The trap of explaining everything
It is natural to want friends and colleagues to understand. A public falsehood can create a powerful urge to produce a complete account, identify every contradiction and make the record unambiguous.
My experience was that repeatedly explaining myself to an informal audience could keep the drama alive. Some listeners were already committed to an interpretation. Others were interested in the unfolding argument. Still others might pass the explanation back to the person involved.
The quotation about friends not needing explanations and enemies not believing them captures my frustration with this cycle. It is best understood as a boundary around endless social persuasion. It should not prevent a clear factual account being given to police, legal advisers, an employer or someone responsible for safeguarding. Those are different conversations with different purposes.
Minimise, de-escalate and create distance
The approach I describe in the recording is to minimise public engagement, reduce escalation and create distance. That includes asking genuine supporters to avoid arguing on your behalf or contacting the person to settle matters.
Public silence can be difficult when the other account remains visible. It may feel like surrendering the story. Yet every new exchange can provide material for further argument, while the target becomes increasingly occupied with an audience that has no responsibility for resolving the situation.
Distance is also relevant to people who repeatedly insist that you simply comply with a demand. They may imagine a straightforward bargain where the actual pattern is one of changing requirements. Their certainty about a solution does not make it a safe or effective one.
When the demands keep changing
A recurring theme in the series is the promise that one action will bring peace: provide an explanation, make an apology, hand something over or agree to a meeting. The difficulty arises when compliance is followed by another demand.
In that pattern, the requested item may function as a reason to keep the interaction going. It is therefore useful to distinguish a bounded practical issue from a continuing claim on access, attention or control. Where money, property, contracts or shared responsibilities are involved, obtain advice and use an appropriate formal channel.
There is no reliable timetable for other people to recognise what is happening. In the video I suggest that contradictory behaviour may become clearer when it receives no public response. That is a possibility, not a guarantee. A person’s safety and support should not depend on eventually winning the court of public opinion.
Read the stalking series
- Stalking and the Problem of Other People
- Stalking, Manipulation and the Two Kinds of Lie
- When Stalking Begins: Before the Target Recognises It
- What Does a Stalker Want? Responses, Boundaries and Their Limits
See also On Stalking and Being Stalked and the General Writings hub.
Support and source material
Watch the original video. For support with your own circumstances, contact the National Stalking Helpline.
This is an edited account of the video, with historical observations distinguished from present-day guidance. Individual safety and legal decisions require advice appropriate to the circumstances.