From The Rainbow Machine: Tales from a Neurolinguist’s Journal by Andrew T. Austin.
A practitioner can spend a great deal of effort sounding like a practitioner. The client may be occupied with something much simpler: the pace is too fast, they need the toilet, or they cannot see how the conversation relates to the life they want. Direct feedback can expose that difference with uncomfortable precision.
“Painting the Dog” in The Rainbow Machine concerns some of my earliest learning as a hypnotherapist. The useful lessons came not only from training but also from volunteers who were willing to tell me what the experience was like from their side of the room.
The memory that nearly named the book
Painting the Dog was originally a working title for the book. In discussion with Steve Andreas, we decided that The Rainbow Machine was a better choice. The other title risked suggesting a book about mistreating animals rather than a collection of experiences and observations.
The phrase came from a man recalling what he experienced as his happiest memory during a hypnotic regression exercise. He described being six years old and painting the family dog. According to his account, his mother then had to shave the dog to remove the paint.
What interested me was the ordinary, particular quality of the memory. Happiness had not arrived as an abstract ideal or an impressive achievement. It was attached to a childhood event that meant something to him. The account is a recollection offered in an exercise, not an independently verified record, and certainly not a suggestion to repeat the activity with an animal.
Discovering that hypnosis could be learned
When I first encountered an advertisement for Ericksonian hypnotherapy training, I knew very little about the subject. The course was run by Stephen Brooks through British Hypnosis Research at the Royal Masonic Hospital. It lasted nearly a year and became an important starting point for my work.
My knowledge at the beginning was so limited that I initially confused Milton Erickson with Erik Erikson. Discovering whose work we were studying prompted me to read further. I also discovered that this was something I could learn to do well, which mattered to a young person who had not previously found many things at which he felt especially capable.
Enthusiasm did not make me experienced. It gave me a reason to practise, pay attention and find out what happened when actual people encountered the things I was learning.
Volunteers who could tell me the truth
I was working in a large teaching hospital and had access to many potential volunteers. I put up notices explaining that I was a trainee hypnotherapist looking for people willing to help me practise. People volunteered in considerable numbers, and I gained experience of different responses to language, procedures and expectations.
Some of my early recruitment language was irreverent about my lack of experience. The useful principle was being clear that I was learning, not presenting myself as an established expert. Training practice still requires informed consent, appropriate supervision and work within the trainee’s competence.
Practising repeatedly helped me become familiar with the procedures. Asking for feedback did something different: it showed me aspects of the encounter that were invisible from my own perspective. Someone could appear to be having difficulty with hypnosis while actually struggling with a very ordinary problem I had failed to notice.
The details my theory did not explain
One volunteer told me I spoke too quickly. Another had needed the toilet but felt too embarrassed to interrupt, which made concentration difficult. Someone thought I was too young to be a convincing hypnotist and had expected an older man with a beard and a limp.
Another person noticed that I was not wearing shoes. I could regard my own manner as relaxed and informal while the person opposite experienced it as a mismatch with the professional help they expected. Neither elaborate language patterns nor a new induction would necessarily resolve that mismatch.
These comments were not all instructions to obey literally. I could not change my age to satisfy an expectation. They were information about how people interpreted the situation. I could change pace, make it easier to request a break, explain my role and think more carefully about presentation.
Feedback also needs an invitation that can survive an unwelcome answer. Asking whether a session was wonderful is different from asking what made it difficult to participate. A person who depends on the practitioner’s approval may need explicit reassurance that criticism will not damage the relationship.
The camera and the salesman
One comment puzzled me at first: I sounded too much like a salesman. I did not properly understand it until I bought a video camera and watched myself working with a client.
What I saw was uncomfortable. I was promoting the idea of change, talking in ways designed to make it sound persuasive, rather than consistently helping the person make a change. The performance had become an activity in its own right. The volunteer’s earlier observation suddenly made sense.
Recording can reveal pace, interruptions, repeated phrases and the amount of time a practitioner spends speaking. It can also expose the difference between an intention and its delivery. Where sessions are recorded for learning, the purpose, consent, access and secure handling of the recording need to be clear. A training recording is not automatically material for public promotion.
What people wanted from the work
I asked people what they would want from an ideal hypnotherapist and what they hoped would be different afterwards. I grouped the responses into four broad themes: being happier, having more friends or being more popular, having more money, and improving sex and relationships.
Those were my categories for the answers I received, not a universal survey of human motivation. They nevertheless made an important point. People were interested in their lives. They were not necessarily looking for an encounter that displayed the full range of a practitioner’s training.
A broad wish still needs to become specific. Wanting better relationships might involve speaking to a partner, setting a boundary, managing a recurring conflict or meeting people. Wanting more money may require practical changes that therapy alone cannot supply. The task is to understand what help is wanted and whether the service being offered can reasonably provide it.
Use the part of the repertoire that the person needs
Training introduces models, patterns, techniques and terminology. Learning them can be valuable. The mistake is assuming that every client needs a demonstration of all of them, or that a session becomes better by containing more of the practitioner’s repertoire.
Sometimes a session is longer because the practitioner has more to deliver, rather than because the person needs more work. Sometimes titles, memberships and specialist vocabulary become ways to establish the helper’s importance while the client’s actual request remains poorly understood.
Simplicity is not the same as promising an instant result. Some problems need sustained work or specialist care. It means removing what has no useful role in the task, explaining the work in ordinary language and resisting the urge to turn every difficulty into a grand account of personal transformation.
Starting a practice by being useful
Asked what I would do if starting again, I would build on the useful contacts and learning available in a medical setting. One idea is a focused teaching session offered to an appropriate hospital education team: a subject relevant to staff, presented clearly and within a manageable amount of time.
I imagined a one-hour slot containing about forty minutes of teaching, ten minutes for questions and ten minutes for people to arrive and return to work. Repeating a short session at different times could make attendance easier for staff with different commitments. The exact format would need agreement with the service, rather than assumptions about its present training arrangements.
Support for people frightened of needles was one topic I considered. Any such teaching would need to fit clinical guidance and the audience’s competence. A brief workshop should not be promoted as a guaranteed rapid cure for every phobia. A useful handout, clear learning aim and accurate limits matter more than an impressive promise.
I also considered practical reminders such as an information pack or contact details on a pen. Their purpose would be to make useful work easy to remember and follow up, rather than to substitute promotional objects for a worthwhile session.
Relationships that continue beyond training
Trainee clinicians become clinicians. A helpful relationship formed early can develop into a network in which people exchange knowledge, discuss research and make appropriate referrals. My own contacts from clinical work have continued to be valuable over many years.
I ran an NLP and hypnosis group at Southampton General Hospital and found interest in the work. That experience makes me question the automatic claim that hospital staff will reject anything involving hypnosis or NLP. It does not mean every service will accept every proposal, but rejection should not be assumed before a relevant, credible offer has been made.
Approaching clinicians also means being prepared to learn from them. Explain what you can do, be precise about evidence and limits, and understand the demands of their work. A useful contribution can be small and specific. It does not need the language of a guaranteed new career or financial freedom to make it worth offering.
More from The Rainbow Machine
Explore the Rainbow Machine article index for the full collection on communication, learning, therapeutic encounters and the assumptions practitioners bring to their work.