From The Rainbow Machine: Tales from a Neurolinguist’s Journal by Andrew T. Austin.

Many activities have a recognisable stopping point. The door is closed, the task is finished, the information has been obtained, and attention moves elsewhere. Other activities keep returning to their beginning. The person checks, acts and checks again, but the experience that would allow them to stop never seems to arrive.

A useful question is therefore not only “Why does this behaviour start?” but “What tells the person it can end?” This question has applications to everyday habits and relationships. It also offers one way of describing aspects of compulsive behaviour, provided it is not mistaken for a complete explanation of obsessive compulsive disorder.

An email that became part of a book

The material behind the Endless Loops and Obsessions and Compulsions chapters began with an email from Steve Andreas. I already knew his work, had read books by members of the Andreas family and admired their contributions to NLP. Receiving a question from him about OCD was exciting.

I began writing a short reply. It became longer and more detailed, partly because I wanted to give a useful answer and partly because I was keen to make a good impression. Much of that exchange was later reworked into the book. What began as a response to a colleague helped me see that I could write a collection of observations and stories.

The two chapters were originally one piece and were separated during editing. Their common interest is the organisation of repetitive behaviour and the point at which an activity can be regarded as complete.

Test, operate, test, exit

The TOTE model describes a sequence: test, operate, test, exit. First, compare the current situation with a criterion. If an action is needed, do something. Then compare again. When the relevant criterion is met, leave that sequence and move on.

For an ordinary task, the criterion might be straightforward. A drawer is open, so close it. Observe that it is closed, then continue with the next activity. The second test allows completion to count. Without an effective route out, the sequence can become test, operate, test, operate, repeatedly.

I encountered this model through early NLP teaching. Its value for me was that it directed attention to the sequence of an activity, including what maintained it and how it ended. A diagram can make a question clearer. It cannot, by itself, establish the cause of a clinical condition.

The wardrobe door that did not feel closed

I remember a documentary showing a woman repeatedly opening and closing a wardrobe door. She could perform the physical action, but the door did not feel closed to her. Opening it and closing it again failed to produce the completion she was seeking, so the operation continued.

That is a secondhand observation from a documentary, not a patient I assessed. My interpretation was that the action and the expected feeling of completion were not joining up in the way the person needed. More sensory evidence was not necessarily satisfying the criterion she was using.

The example raises an important distinction between a condition in the world and a feeling of certainty about it. A door can be visibly shut while the person still experiences a powerful demand to repeat the action. Telling them that the answer is obvious does not address what makes the repetition feel necessary.

The experience may concern a feared consequence, a sense that things are not right, or another form of distress. The practitioner needs to ask rather than supply the answer. A model is useful when it improves that inquiry, not when it announces what must be happening in every case.

The button that must keep being pressed

Tamagotchi virtual pets supplied an everyday analogy. When the devices were popular, I remember nurses bringing them to work because their children could not take them to school. Little devices would sound at the nurses’ station, requiring someone to attend to them so that the virtual pet remained alive.

A fictional button-pressing routine in the television series Lost interested me for a similar reason. The action has to be repeated because stopping is associated with a feared consequence. The person is occupied not simply with completing a task but with preventing what might happen if the task is abandoned.

These are analogies for a pattern, not equivalents of OCD. A game has programmed rules and a fictional story has a designed plot. A person’s distress requires its own assessment. The useful question is what the person expects, feels or fears when the usual operation is not performed.

Revising the software explanation

In my earlier writing I leaned towards describing OCD as a software problem: an unhelpful programme that could be changed by reorganising a strategy. Further experience, including work that did not succeed as I had hoped, made me less confident in that account.

The hardware and software distinction is itself a metaphor. Human biology and psychological experience are not separate components that can be assigned cleanly to one side. It would be a mistake to infer that because a repetitive sequence can be described, the condition is therefore easy to change through an NLP procedure.

It would be equally mistaken to infer that a biological contribution makes psychological treatment pointless. NHS guidance on OCD treatment describes CBT with exposure and response prevention, and medication may also be offered. Treatment is planned around the individual and the impact of the symptoms.

Exposure and response prevention is not simply an instruction to stop a ritual and endure whatever happens. It is a structured therapeutic approach. A person struggling with compulsions deserves support from someone competent in treating OCD, rather than a promise that a clever question will make the difficulty disappear.

A preference for order is not a diagnosis

The casual use of diagnostic labels can obscure the scale and variety of a condition. Saying “I am a bit OCD” because one likes a tidy desk does not communicate the experience of someone whose checking, washing or mental rituals consume large parts of life.

At the same time, visible severity is not the only way to recognise suffering. Compulsions can be mental and hidden, and someone does not need to display damaged hands or a dramatic public ritual for their difficulty to deserve assessment. A brief impression should not be used to declare that a person does or does not have OCD.

This matters when evaluating therapeutic claims. If a practitioner calls an ordinary preference a disorder and then changes the preference, they have not demonstrated that the same method treats a diagnosed condition. Clear descriptions of the starting problem, the intervention and what happened afterwards are more useful than a dramatic label.

Everyday activities without an ending

The stopping question also interested me in less clinical settings. On a training course I met a charismatic participant who described cocaine use and a life in which activities repeatedly went to extremes. He wanted greater control but seemed to have difficulty recognising when to stop.

I thought about familiar patterns of anger too. As a child, I passed a house where a man regularly argued with schoolchildren from his garden gate. Some children answered him back, and the exchange kept supplying each side with another reason to continue. My childhood theory about the origin of his anger was speculation. The repeated interaction was what I could actually observe.

Years later, an angry man approached me as I got out of a car near a supermarket. Before becoming drawn into the argument, I asked, “How does this end?” He appeared thrown by the question. I said I needed to do my shopping and went inside. He was gone when I returned.

That incident does not prove that the question resolved his anger. I did not know what had upset him, and I was keen to leave a potentially unsafe interaction. What the question did for me was direct attention away from winning the exchange and towards whether participating in it served any purpose.

Finding a workable stopping point

For an ordinary recurring argument, the useful criterion might be that your position has been stated and another exchange is unlikely to add information. For a task, it may be an agreed standard rather than an unlimited search for perfection. For guilt, useful work may involve an appropriate repair or changed behaviour rather than repeating self-punishment indefinitely.

These examples should not become a demand for perfect certainty or another checking ritual. The aim is a workable boundary that allows the next part of life to happen. If attempts to define that boundary intensify distress or become compulsive themselves, that is material to discuss with an appropriate professional.

Ask what the activity is trying to achieve, what would count as enough and whether that standard can realistically be met. Where the situation involves another person, consider which decisions belong to you and which do not. An ending need not mean that everything has been solved or that everyone agrees. Sometimes it means recognising the point at which repeating the same operation is no longer useful.

0 0 votes
Article Rating
Subscribe
Notify of
guest
0 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
0
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x
()
x