There is a difference between believing that something is true and fearing that it might be true. The words used to describe the two can sound remarkably similar. A person may speak with great detail about a feared event while still being uncertain about it. If a practitioner hears certainty where there is actually fear, the conversation can head in the wrong direction.
“Voodoo Science” explores that distinction through an encounter with a man who thought a former partner had cursed him. His distress deserved attention. The supernatural explanation did not need to be accepted as fact in order to understand why the possibility had become so troubling.
The feared power of an ex-partner
The man came to see me partly because he knew of my interest in occult and alchemical traditions. He described his former partner as a witch and attributed a range of physical, emotional and spiritual difficulties to a curse. That description provided an explanation for what was happening to him and placed the source of control outside himself.
My own interest in esoteric systems has largely concerned their philosophical, symbolic and practical dimensions. It does not require accepting claims that someone can remotely cause illness by performing a ritual. An identity, title or reputation for unusual powers is not evidence that the claimed powers exist.
Nevertheless, a feared possibility can influence how someone interprets ordinary events. Once the curse becomes a candidate explanation, a difficult day, a bodily sensation or an unrelated setback may be placed inside the same account. The explanation gathers details, and the gathering of details can make the explanation feel more substantial.
Conviction and uncertainty are different experiences
One question I found useful was whether the man actually held a settled conviction or was frightened that his former partner might have such power. Those are different positions. An argument intended to disprove a belief may fail to address someone whose difficulty is the inability to tolerate a possibility.
The distinction appears in ordinary life too. Someone can fear that a relationship is failing without believing it definitely is. They can repeatedly imagine a disaster while recognising that it is unlikely. The amount of attention devoted to a possibility does not by itself tell us how certain the person is that it will happen.
It would be a mistake, however, to generalise this observation into the claim that people experiencing psychosis never believe what they say. Conviction varies, and delusions can be firmly held. NHS information on psychosis describes how real these beliefs and experiences can feel to the person affected. A useful distinction for one encounter is not a substitute for clinical assessment.
Questions can accidentally enlarge the story
A practitioner may ask for more and more detail because they think they are discovering the structure of a belief. Who is responsible? How are they doing it? When did the power begin? What else have they caused? But a detailed conversation is not necessarily a clarifying conversation.
If the person is frightened and uncertain, such questions may invite them to elaborate an explanation they had not previously developed. The interaction can begin to reward speculation. Both people become occupied with the alleged mechanism while the immediate distress, sleep, safety and support needs receive less attention.
More useful questions distinguish experience from interpretation. What has the person actually noticed? What are they afraid may happen? How certain do they feel? What makes the fear stronger or weaker? What help do they need now? These questions make room for uncertainty without insisting on a confrontation about the entire worldview.
The historical ritual and its limits
At the time of this encounter I was living in a small bedsit lined with books. I took down an occult text and worked with the man on a symbolic design and a ritual intended to address his fear. I sent him away while I prepared what I would give him, then went through it with him when he returned.
What interested me was the interpersonal change created by treating the concern with sustained seriousness. I wondered whether my very detailed response might make him notice his own uncertainty. Perhaps part of him would begin to think that I was taking the story more literally than he did. That was my interpretation of what the interaction might be doing, not something I could directly observe inside his mind.
The account is not evidence that a curse existed, that a ritual removed one, or that occult procedures treat psychosis. It also raises a practical risk: a response framed as protection from a curse can strengthen the belief that a curse is present. For that reason, the transferable lesson is the importance of taking distress seriously, rather than copying the supernatural explanation or prescribing a protective ritual.
Validation does not require factual agreement
When someone is frightened, an immediate dismissal can leave them feeling unheard as well as afraid. A response such as “that sounds frightening” recognises the emotional experience. It does not mean “your explanation is correct”. The distinction allows the practitioner to remain both respectful and grounded.
One can acknowledge that a person has been preoccupied, has slept badly or feels unsafe without agreeing that an unseen force is acting on them. It is also possible to ask about real events in a relationship without accepting that supernatural causation explains them. The conversation can attend to what is known, what is feared and what remains uncertain.
Validation is not a technique for pretending to agree until the person becomes easier to influence. It is an honest recognition of the experience they are describing. If the practitioner does not share the explanation, that can be expressed calmly without ridicule or a contest over who is more rational.
Delirium needs a different clinical response
Confusion after surgery, severe illness or a change in mental state should not be treated as though it were simply an ordinary belief to reframe. The surrounding medical context matters. A person may need assessment for delirium and investigation of underlying causes.
It is also too broad to say that orientation never helps. NICE guidance on delirium recommends identifying and managing causes, effective communication, reassurance and appropriate reorientation, such as explaining where the person is and who is caring for them. Repeated argumentative correction is different from calm, supportive orientation.
The distinction illustrates a larger point: superficially similar statements can arise in different circumstances. A frightened person considering an unlikely possibility, a person with a fixed delusion and a patient with acute confusion may need different forms of help. The shared presence of an unusual explanation does not make the situations interchangeable.
Taking action can change what a person notices
Another hospital encounter stayed with me because of the timing of a patient’s realisation. After an uncomfortable colonoscopy that appeared reassuring to the clinician, the man remarked that he had suspected his recent bowel concerns were connected with changes in what his wife was feeding him. The procedure seemed to prompt him to formulate an everyday explanation he had not previously settled on.
That does not retrospectively prove the procedure was unnecessary or establish the cause of his symptoms. It shows how an event can change what somebody is ready to notice or say. The clinician and the patient may also understand the significance of the same event quite differently.
For the man frightened of a curse, the question was similarly about what became possible within the encounter. Could his concern be heard without becoming an unquestionable account of the world? Could uncertainty be acknowledged without humiliation? Could support be organised around his actual distress? Those are practical questions that do not require anyone to possess extraordinary powers.
Part of The Rainbow Machine: Tales from a Neurolinguist’s Journal by Andrew T. Austin.