From The Rainbow Machine: Tales from a Neurolinguist’s Journal by Andrew T. Austin.
“Part of me wants to do it, but another part refuses.” Such language provides an immediately understandable description of conflict. It lets a person distinguish competing wishes without having to resolve them in the first sentence. A therapeutic conversation can use that description productively.
A difficulty arises when the therapist turns a useful way of speaking into a requirement about how the person must be organised. Because the practitioner knows a parts technique, the client is expected to have parts. The method starts defining the experience it was supposed to help investigate.
Discovering parts work through NLP
My introduction came through NLP’s six-step reframe, before I undertook formal NLP training. At the time I ran a hypnosis group at Southampton General Hospital. We met in a room in the teaching wing, usually every other week, with a core group of regulars and others who came to see what we were doing.
The hospital setting brought people with medical, psychiatric and psychological experience into the room. That made it an interesting place to practise and exchange ideas. I had studied Ericksonian hypnotherapy and was developing my skills, but my knowledge of NLP was still limited.
Two medical students visited, and one handed me Richard Bandler and John Grinder’s Frogs into Princes. Reading it introduced me to ways of examining experience that I had not previously considered. The six-step reframe led me towards parts work and towards the wider influences associated with early NLP.
I became interested in the use of an empty chair for imagined conversations and in Virginia Satir’s parts-party approach. Different methods give inner positions a form in which they can interact. The question that began to concern me was whether we were working with distinctions the person already experienced or teaching them to organise themselves according to our preferred procedure.
Using a distinction and installing one
If someone says that they are fighting with themselves, there is already a distinction to explore. What is doing the fighting, what is being opposed and how does the conflict unfold? Their language supplies the starting point. It need not be treated as evidence of literal separate beings inside the person.
It is different when a practitioner announces that a part must exist, requires it to have a name and insists that it answer questions. The client may comply with the exercise while learning that their experience is only acceptable when expressed through the therapist’s categories.
Imagination can be useful without being mistaken for discovery. An invitation such as “Would it help to describe this as two competing positions?” leaves room for a refusal. “What is the name of the part responsible?” presupposes both the part and its responsibility. That difference is small in wording and substantial in consequence.
The concern becomes especially important around memory. A vivid image or an answer generated during an exercise is not independent proof of an event. The American Psychological Association’s guidance on memories of childhood abuse discusses the complexity of remembered, forgotten and suggested material. Therapy should support the person without deciding in advance what their history must contain.
Demons as personified experience
My interest in ceremonial magic offered an unusual comparison. In a psychological reading of a ritual, a magician who evokes a demon can be understood as giving a troubling quality a personified form. The aim may then be to establish a different relationship with it instead of remaining tormented by it.
This is an interpretive analogy, not a claim that spirits have been clinically demonstrated or that all magical traditions mean the same thing. It interested me because the relationship resembles aspects of parts work: identify a troublesome pattern, represent it in a form that can be addressed and change the relationship.
The comparison also raises a warning. A dramatic ritual can create the impression of an entity before claiming to remove or control it. A therapist can make a similar mistake by first supplying an elaborate explanation of hidden inner agents and then presenting themselves as the specialist required to manage them.
The spectacle is not the evidence. It matters whether the person gains useful choices, whether distress changes and whether their capacity to act independently increases. A procedure that makes an experience more frightening or mysterious may be moving in the wrong direction even when it appears impressive.
The person in your head is a representation
Consider an unresolved argument with a parent. The parent is absent, yet their familiar phrases continue inside the argument. You answer, they object and you answer again. The interaction may feel interpersonal, but the present conversation is with an internal representation of that person.
The word introject can be used for an internalised representation of this kind. Remembering that distinction matters. The actual person is not supplying every line that appears in the imagined dialogue. Your representation may be based on real experience while also being selective, repetitive and unable to learn anything new.
People can represent experience as a person, an object, an animal or a more abstract quality. A black cloud, a demanding character and a pursuing creature offer different ways of organising a difficulty. None requires the practitioner to assume that the metaphor is a literal description of mental anatomy.
Keeping an intention while changing a behaviour
One aspect of the six-step reframe that appealed to me was the distinction between an intention and the behaviour used to pursue it. Within the model, the aim is to explore whether something the person values could be served by a different response. There is less need for an endless internal battle if another workable option becomes available.
That positive-intention frame is a therapeutic proposal. It should not be imposed as a fact about every symptom or used to excuse harmful behaviour. A person may find the question useful, may disagree with its premise, or may need a different approach altogether.
I also spent a sustained period exploring Core Transformation in my own practice, applying it to recurring patterns and internal representations. The method developed by Connirae Andreas works through a sequence of intended outcomes towards what it calls core states. The book Core Transformation: Reaching the Wellspring Within was written by Connirae and Tamara Andreas. My enthusiasm for it comes from my experience of the process; it should not be confused with a guarantee of treatment results.
When a feeling becomes an identity
“I feel depressed,” “I have depression” and “I am a depressive” arrange experience differently. The first describes a feeling, the second names a condition and the third makes a statement about identity. These forms can coexist, but it is worth hearing the shift rather than assuming the sentences are interchangeable.
A diagnosis may help someone obtain treatment and understand a recurring condition. It need not define every aspect of the person or imply that their experience can never change. Equally, changing a label does not by itself remove an illness. The point is to keep the language responsive to the person’s present life.
Recovery communities sometimes deliberately retain an identity that acknowledges a continuing vulnerability, even after a long period without the behaviour. That can have meaning and practical value for the people who choose it. A practitioner should explore what an identity does for the individual rather than announcing that it is either always helpful or always limiting.
Participation in change
A difficulty can also acquire the role of an external agent: the depression ruins my life, the anxiety follows me everywhere, the black cloud prevents me doing anything. Such language can communicate suffering vividly. It may also make the person’s own participation in change harder to imagine.
Exploring participation does not mean blaming someone for having symptoms. It means finding out what choices, observations and support are available now. Which parts of daily life can the person influence? What would useful help enable them to do? What remains beyond their control?
Parts work earns its place when it helps a person investigate those questions in language that fits them. The model should remain available for use, revision or rejection. A client does not need to become a convincing illustration of a technique in order to receive help.