From The Rainbow Machine: Tales from a Neurolinguist’s Journal by Andrew T. Austin.
An account of eating that begins and ends with willpower leaves out the setting in which eating happens. Food is displayed, promoted, packaged and associated with reward, convenience, belonging and identity. The decision does not occur in an empty room. It takes place among repeated invitations to consume.
The “Poor Planning” chapter of The Rainbow Machine draws attention to the work of Stanley Schachter and to the distinction between internal and external cues. My own interest moved from asking what was wrong with an individual’s behaviour towards examining the commercial environment surrounding that behaviour.
Internal signals and external invitations
Schachter’s 1968 paper, “Obesity and eating”, examined how internal and external cues affected eating in the groups studied. It is a historical point of reference for asking what prompts eating, rather than assuming that a person eats only because of a straightforward internal signal of hunger.
An external cue might be the presence of an appealing food, the suggestion that it is time to eat, or an occasion in which eating is expected. The useful question is what happened immediately before the decision. Was the food already wanted, or did wanting become noticeable when a prompt appeared?
This is an avenue of inquiry, not a complete theory of weight. A historical experiment does not establish that everyone in a particular body size responds in the same way. Nor does it justify dividing people into morally stronger and weaker categories. The point is to make the surrounding influences visible enough to discuss.
A clinical impression is not a test of suggestibility
In my early hypnosis work, I formed the impression that some of the people who came to me with weight difficulties responded readily to suggestion. That led me to wonder about their susceptibility to commercial messages outside the consulting room. The hypothesis influenced how I thought about the problem.
The distinction needs care. A practitioner’s impression from a selected group of clients is not evidence that body size predicts hypnotisability. Someone’s weight cannot tell us how they will respond to hypnosis, and responding to a hypnotic exercise is not the same thing as being unable to resist advertising. Those would require separate evidence.
What survives that qualification is a practical question: how is this particular person influenced? Which messages catch their attention, what do those messages imply, and what happens next? That question can be explored without turning an observation into a universal diagnosis.
Food is an unavoidable market
People can decide never to buy many products. Food presents a different problem because eating is necessary. A person attempting to change an eating pattern still has to make decisions about food, repeatedly, while encountering the same shops, packaging and social expectations.
The commercial task of increasing sales can therefore conflict with a person’s aim to buy or eat differently. A larger portion can be framed as better value. An additional purchase can be framed as a reward. A familiar product can become associated with an ordinary part of every day. The customer’s difficulty is not simply ignorance of an instruction to eat less.
There is evidence that food marketing matters. The World Health Organization’s guideline on marketing to children describes effects on food choices, intake, purchase requests and norms about consumption. That supports taking marketing seriously. It does not mean that every marketing effect is hypnosis or that advertising alone explains every person’s weight.
Read the product, not only the promise
When I began paying closer attention to my own diet, I looked more carefully at prepared foods and their ingredients. The difference between the message on the front of a pack and the detail of what it contained caught my attention. A reassuring description of one feature could distract from other features worth considering.
A claim such as “low fat” is a statement about one aspect of a product. It is not a complete nutritional assessment. Rather than assume that every product carrying a particular claim is either beneficial or harmful, compare the actual information and the amount ordinarily consumed.
The same principle applies to the shopping environment. Notice which products are made prominent, what counts as an offer, how portions are presented and what is positioned as the natural extra purchase. These observations can be made directly. Claims about a particular shop using artificial smells or specific sensory techniques should not be assumed without evidence about that shop.
Selling a way of being
My visits to India, beginning in 1993, made changes in food culture especially noticeable to me. I saw international fast-food brands become more visible, and I was struck by how their products could be associated with being modern, fashionable or successful. The appeal was not limited to taste.
One conversation captured the difference in expectations. Asked how often I went to McDonald’s, I replied that it was perhaps about once a year. The surprise concerned the assumption that it was a normal place to go for dinner. What I regarded as an occasional purchase occupied a different place in the other person’s idea of ordinary eating.
These are personal observations, not population data establishing a national trend or its causes. Their relevance is the way a product acquires a social role. A meal can signal participation in a valued identity, and changing the meal may then feel like giving up more than the food itself.
Blame is an inadequate explanation
When a difficulty is widespread, explaining it entirely as individual weakness is especially unhelpful. It is reasonable to ask what has changed in availability, cost, working arrangements, marketing and daily life. At the same time, replacing individual blame with a single commercial cause would also oversimplify the issue.
The NHS account of overweight and obesity recognises several contributing factors and a range of forms of support. Biology, health conditions, medicines and circumstances can matter alongside eating and activity. A person deserves an assessment relevant to their situation, rather than an assumption based on appearance.
Rejecting humiliation does not require denying health concerns. Discussing health concerns does not require humiliating people. Those principles can coexist with scrutiny of commercial practices. A person should not have to defend an industry in order to defend their right to be treated decently.
Planning around the cue, not only the intention
A useful starting point is to examine one repeated sequence. What situation comes first? What food is visible or available? Which message appears in the person’s thinking? Is the purchase planned, habitual, socially expected or prompted by an offer? What options are actually accessible at that moment?
The purpose is information, not a new occasion for self-attack. A record that notices work patterns, cost and convenience may identify a practical obstacle that a promise to try harder misses. A change in what is available or when a decision is made may be more usable than another attempt to resist the same cue repeatedly.
Awareness does not make anyone immune to influence, and planning cannot remove every constraint. It can make the next decision more concrete. Instead of asking only why a person failed to keep an intention, ask what repeatedly competed with that intention and what support would make a different choice realistic.
More from The Rainbow Machine
Browse the Rainbow Machine article index for related material on planning, motivation, learning and the assumptions behind therapeutic explanations.